Let's talk about the Pixel's crazy new on-screen keys

So the first proper render of one of the new Google Pixel phones has leaked out, and with it we're getting a look at some new UI tweaks in that device's software. The Pixel phones put the Google brand front and center, and so we're seeing some significant UI tweaks — not least of which is in Android's soft keys.

The new key layout uses a solid triangle, circle and square for the three main Android keys, with the home key having a white border around it. It's not a huge departure from the outlined icons of old, but it is a significant change to a part of the Android UI you'll be looking at an awful lot.

The new-style home button is a big visual differentiator from other Android phones.

There's no suggestion that these new-style buttons will come to other Android devices, Nexus or otherwise, with the arrival of the first Nougat maintenance release (Android 7.1). Indeed, our money would be on this style of button being unique to Google's Pixel devices. We'll have to wait and see on that, though.

We'll also have to hold out on whether there'll be any animation changes accompanying the new button style. Right now on Android 7.0, there's a familiar glowing effect when you tap the on-screen buttons, and Screen Search (formerly Google Now) expands to form a border around the screen when you long-press the home key. With Google (and its services) taking a more central role in the software, it'll be interesting to see whether the visuals of Screen Search — or simple button taps, for that matter — are also changed.

The new keys also raise a few concerns over possible image burn-in on phones with AMOLED screens, as the Pixel and Pixel XL are rumored to have. Since you're you're lighting up more pixels more often compared to the old hollowed-out icons, any burn-in could be more noticeable. (That's almost certainly something Google's factored into its design process, though.)

Android's on-screen keys: A brief history

Android 3.x Honeycomb — Tron-style

Honeycomb buttons

Honeycomb was weird — a tablet-only release of Android in 2011 that never really took off, with an oddball sci-fi UI. And that extended to glowing blue soft keys — a first for Android at the time — with sharp edges and bold outlines.

Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich - 4.4 KitKat — Holo-style

ICS buttons

In late 2011, Ice Cream Sandwich toned down the overtly futuristic visual style of Android, bringing a cleaner button layout with more consistent lines and a curvy back arrow. This button style would stick around through to KitKat in 2013.

Android 5.0 Lollipop - 7.0 Nougat — Material-style

Material Design buttons

Lollipop introduced Material Design, a major design overhaul for the whole of Android, and other Google properties. And with it, Android's on-screen keys became simpler and more geometric, with small outlined shapes for each key.

Pixel phones (Android 7.1 Nougat) — Google-style

Pixel buttons

The new Pixel phones are more Google-focused than ever before. So it's only natural to see this reflected in the devices' new button layout, with solid shapes extra prominence given to the home key, which is used to activate Screen Search (formerly Google Now).

Love 'em? Hate 'em? Share your thoughts on the Pixel's new-style soft keys in the comments below!

Alex Dobie
Executive Editor

Alex was with Android Central for over a decade, producing written and video content for the site, and served as global Executive Editor from 2016 to 2022.

Read more
Looking at the homescreen while holding a Google Pixel 9
Here’s our first look at Google’s upcoming icon shape customization for Pixel phones
Using Google Circle to Search on a Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Google could make Circle to Search slicker with a transparent navigation bar
Close-up of the Peony Google Pixel 9a, focused on the camera cutout and LED.
Here's why the Google Pixel 9a ditched the camera bar
Incoming call UI
Google could be testing a 'new' way to answer phone calls
Google Messages left-panel menu
Google Messages is shaking things up again for better or worse
The Peony Google Pixel 9a held in hand in front of a houseplant.
Google Pixel 9a hands-on: Extreme makeover, phone edition
Latest in Apps & Software
YouTube Premium homepage on Android
YouTube's notification test impacts channels you rarely interact with
Google Pixel 8a
Google tipped to bring text-based actions in AI Overviews for Circle to Search
A Qualcomm Snapdragon 8 Elite placard at a press event
Qualcomm's 'Elite' branding should stay exclusive to Oryon-based chips
The promotional image for Google Workspace feature drops.
The March Workspace feature drop upgrades Gemini's note-taking and translation tools
Google discusses trends and AI updates to help people travel this summer.
Google prepares you for a hot summer with new AI updates for traveling
YouTube Music home screen
YouTube Music's personalized radio stations are getting even smarter
Latest in News
The Light Phone III in lifestyle photos.
The Light Phone 3 is here with miniature features, massive $799 price tag
YouTube Premium homepage on Android
YouTube's notification test impacts channels you rarely interact with
Google Pixel 8a
Google tipped to bring text-based actions in AI Overviews for Circle to Search
Pixel Watch 3 run coaching suggestion in the Fitbit app on a Pixel 9
Fitbit's Health Metrics are getting a redesign on Android and iOS
The Galaxy S24 Plus in hand with a light behind it
Samsung's sixth One UI 7 beta for the Galaxy S24 rolls out as launch nears
The promotional image for Google Workspace feature drops.
The March Workspace feature drop upgrades Gemini's note-taking and translation tools