Broadband companies submitted fake comments to derail net neutrality

Council Member Letitia James
Council Member Letitia James (Image credit: Wikimedia Commons)

What you need to know

  • New York Attorney General says millions of comments to FCC proceeding on net neutrality were fake.
  • Broadband companies initiated the campaign to generate fake comments.
  • Three firms that help generate comments were charged $4.9 million.

The nation's largest broadband companies, which includes some of the best wireless carriers in the U.S., funded a secret campaign to generate millions of fake comments to the Federal Communications Commission during its repeal of net neutrality rules in 2017, according to the New York Attorney General's office (NYAGO).

The investigation, which was released today, indicated that many of the comments provided "cover" for the repeal of the rules. The investigation indicated that the broadband companies engaged "commercial lead generators" that would use prizes, like gift cards or sweepstakes, to lure consumers to their websites and join the campaign.

The three firms were charged $4.9 million in penalties and disgorgement and have been told to "adopt comprehensive reforms in future advocacy campaigns."

The NYAGO found in its investigation that more than 8.5 million fake comments impersonating real people were submitted to the FCC, and more than half a million fake letters were sent to Congress.

The investigation further noted that 9.3 million fake comments that supported net neutrality used fake identities. It said that 18 million out of the more than 22 million comments submitted during the 2017 proceeding were fake.

"Instead of actually looking for real responses from the American people, marketing companies are luring vulnerable individuals to their websites with freebies, co-opting their identities, and fabricating responses that giant corporations are then using to influence the policies and laws that govern our lives," New York Attorney General Letitia James said in a press release.

"Today we are taking action to root out this fraud and the impersonation that has been corrupting the process for far too long."

Android Central reached out to the NYAGO to know which broadband companies were involved, but did not get a response in time for publication.

The report however indicates that the campaign was run through Broadband for America, a group that includes Comcast, Charter, AT&T, Cox and CenturyLink. It adds that Comcast, Charter, and AT&T are the biggest members of Broadband for America.

In 2017, the FCC voted in favor of removing tough net neutrality rules that were put in place to prevent internet providers from blocking and throttling traffic and offering paid fast lanes. The new rules now indicate that companies can do this practice, so long as they publicly state they will do it.

Today's investigation report also includes recommendations on avoiding this from happening again in the future. Those include advocacy groups ensuring they obtain valid consent from individuals before submitting comments; agencies and legislatures that get comments to hold those submitting accountable; lawmakers to strengthen laws to deter unauthorized submissions; and agencies to adopt technical safeguards.

Shruti Shekar
Editor in Chief

Shruti Shekar is Android Central's Editor-in-Chief. She was born in India, brought up in Singapore, but now lives in Toronto. She started her journalism career as a political reporter in Ottawa, Canada's capital, and then made her foray into tech journalism at MobileSyrup and most recently at Yahoo Finance Canada. When work isn't on her mind, she loves working out, reading, watching the Raptors, and planning what she's going to eat the next day.

Read more
Protect Net Neutrality rally, San Francisco
Net neutrality falls in court ruling that could impact broader big tech regulation
Google Play Store homepage
Google confirms mass app deletion on Play Store after ad fraud
Samsung's Galaxy A16 5G.
News Weekly: Massive OnePlus 13R leak, a new Samsung phone lands in the US, and more
The Snapdragon logo at the Qualcomm booth in Maui for Snapdragon Summit 2024
The iPhone 16e proves we do need Qualcomm for 5G in North America
Android figures
You shouldn't steal eBooks unless you have good lawyers
Google Chrome icon on a laptop screen
Google tightens the reins on Chrome shopping plugins amid Honey link scandal
Latest in Carriers
Satellite SOS notification on Galaxy S25 Ultra
Spectrum and Xfinity Mobile users to get satellite texting with select Android phones
Verizon logo with AC mascot
Verizon US is first to get satellite texting to any device with select Android smartphones
A Meta Quest 3S and its controllers with the retail box
How to get a FREE Meta Quest 3S with this Verizon internet deal — yes, it's real
AST SpaceMobile satellite
Verizon and AT&T test first satellite-based video calls, and it's not Starlink
T-Mobile is working with MLB for the ABS system and MLB.tv
T-Mobile customers can now claim their free MLB.tv access through March 31
Using Google Circle to Search on a Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra
Is TextNow's free wireless plan actually free? Here's the deal
Latest in News
The promotional image for Google Workspace feature drops.
The March Workspace feature drop upgrades Gemini's note-taking and translation tools
The Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge on display
New leak shows off Samsung Galaxy S25 Edge in 'Titanium' variants
YouTube Music home screen
YouTube Music's personalized radio stations are getting even smarter
The back of the Obsidian Google Pixel 9 Pro
Some Pixel owners had a delayed start, thanks to alarm clock failures
Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra Home Screen - 16x9
Heads up — Samsung's detailed One UI 7 rollout schedule for Galaxy appears
Screenshots showing the new Garmin Connect Plus subscription in action on mobile phones above the text "Connect+"
Garmin Connect+ subscription adds Active Intelligence, new workouts and coaching