VR will never replace traditional gaming, and that's perfectly fine

A Meta Quest 2 headset next to a Nintendo Switch, an Xbox controller, Steam Controller, and PS5 controller
(Image credit: Nicholas Sutrich / Android Central)

While some have said over the years that VR will be the next great medium of entertainment — that it will replace all current types of games and ways we watch movies and TV — I think they were dead wrong.

Back in 1980, years before I was born, a song titled "Video killed the radio star" made waves when it launched alongside the new Music Television channel, better known today as MTV. It more than just suggested that music videos would replace audio-only music, ushering in a new visual era of music.

Over the years, music videos and audio-only music live both converged and separated lives with apps like YouTube Music that continually blur the lines between the two seemingly disparate mediums. Spotify's recent TikTok-style redesign further proves that neither video nor radio killed each other. They are stronger in symbiosis.

Likewise, we won't be seeing some future where everyone wears a VR headset all the time and only plays VR games. As gaming has grown, so, too, have the ways people play games. Once upon a time, people only played games on a monitor or TV. These days, anything with a display can play games, and that reality isn't changing any time soon. VR offers a more physical way to interact with your games, but not everyone wants to move that much all the time and that's just fine.

The error of zero-sum thinking

Passing a Meta Quest 2 to someone else

(Image credit: Nicholas Sutrich / Android Central)

If you're a gamer, chances are you've seen the meme "do you guys not have phones?" It originated from BlizzCon 2018 when the developers of Diablo Immortal were booed upon announcing that Immortal was a mobile-only entry in the series.

As if one wing of the massive Activision Blizzard empire couldn't simultaneously develop both a mobile-only and PC/console-only version of the storied franchise.

The best part is that all of them did have phones and, more than likely — based on the money Activision Blizzard made off the game — all of them played Diablo Immortal. Now, we're treated with Diablo IV, a "proper" entry in the series that fans have already started to enjoy on their PCs and consoles.

It's this zero-sum thinking that is killing discourse in the video game industry and, ultimately, causing a lot of strife where none actually exists. In economic terms, a zero-sum game is one in which a win for one side is a direct loss for the other side.

It's a spilling over of political tribalistic behavior that pretends that there are only a finite number of seats of power in the gaming world and that your favorite video game company has to have the most seats to win.

The video game industry is large enough to accommodate different tastes in games without affecting the success of others.

Wake-up call: there is no ceiling here. All of us can play and have fun. The only winners are the gamers — who get to have more fun than ever before — and the developers that get to keep making the games they love because of all the new opportunities.

VR presents a new way to get more physically involved and active by being in the game. Just as handheld gaming machines or smartphones let players take games on the go, VR gives gamers another way to play a game that's different from just sitting on the couch. But it's also OK if you just want to sit on the couch. That's why traditional gaming isn't going anywhere.

So why am I bringing this up now? This week, a new study came out that, as CNBC editorialized, means that teenagers "aren't interested in VR" because only 4% of them play daily.

So I posted about it on Twitter and received a lot of feedback.

The responses run the gamut from folks who are completely uneducated about the success of the Quest (and the fact that it's been outselling the Xbox Series X|S since both systems' debut) to Xbox fanboys accusing me of somehow being a Sony fanboy because I support VR, and everything in-between.

It's a dizzying thread that ate up the majority of my morning and made me realize just how deep this zero-sum type of thinking runs.

Again, it's as if the demise of VR — whether that's Meta itself or the entire medium — will somehow usher in a new era of dominance for games played on a 2D display.

But that's not how it works.

A history of growth

Rough graph showing estimated lifetime sales of each current-gen console in Spring 2022

(Image credit: Nicholas Sutrich / Android Central)

The graphic above is an old one I made for an article I published a year ago, but it illustrates a good point. Some people will look at this graph and see only the idea that their color is winning.

Good for you, I hope you enjoy the feeling of false success earned by being an armchair quarterback.

For the rest of us, however, the graph above means one thing: gaming continues to grow, and the thing we love to pass our time with is only getting bigger, better, and more varied than ever before.

Gaming continues to grow, becoming bigger, better, and more varied than ever before.

Case in point, let's take a look at the sales of consoles in the early days:

(Image credit: Android Central)

While we could get in the weeds and have several conversations around trends in the chart above, I want to focus on the most important column: the total number of gamers.

As each generation progresses and a new contender enters, one particular company might sell more or less than the other but the number of people buying consoles only grows as competition increases. More choices mean that more niches are being filled and, as a result, more people are willing to spend money on games built by developers who love telling stories and pushing the medium forward as an art.

More choices means more gamers and, thus, more games. Just try to enjoy them instead of fighting about it, ok?

The same goes for VR, mobile gaming, handheld gaming, or whatever niche or segment you want to break the market into. No matter how many people buy one system or regularly play one type of game, the rest of the medium doesn't suffer from it.

Just because there are 6.5 billion smartphones being used in the world doesn't mean that no one plays games on a TV or a computer anymore. Just because the PlayStation sells more than the Xbox doesn't mean you can't still enjoy the next Halo game.

People will play games on the device it makes the most sense for them in the moment. Unique experiences like VR headsets and dedicated gaming phones offer more opportunities, not fewer.

As the old saying goes: "can't we just all get along"?

Nicholas Sutrich
Senior Content Producer — Smartphones & VR
Nick started with DOS and NES and uses those fond memories of floppy disks and cartridges to fuel his opinions on modern tech. Whether it's VR, smart home gadgets, or something else that beeps and boops, he's been writing about it since 2011. Reach him on Twitter or Instagram @Gwanatu
Read more
A child holding a Meta Quest 3S with a Yoges head strap
Free-to-play content is winning over Meta Quest 3 players with big consequences in tow
A panel of VR experts on stage at GDC 2025, discussing the "VR gaming visibility crisis."
Quest developers are joining forces to solve the 'VR visibility crisis'
A promo image of the Meta Quest 3 on a grid background surrounded by eight bestselling VR titles in 2024, including Gorilla Tag and Batman: Arkham Shadow.
Meta's head of Oculus Publishing debunked Quest Store 'theories' and hinted at their Quest 4 audience at GDC
A Meta Quest 3 and a Meta Quest 3S headset on a table with a Horizon Worlds portal behind them
Meta, it's time to kill Horizon Worlds before it kills the Meta Quest
Comparing the Meta Quest 3S vs. Quest 3
Best VR headsets 2025
Samsung Project Moohan Android XR headset at Samsung Unpacked 2025
These niche, expensive VR headsets will fill the gap Meta Quest has left behind in 2025
Latest in Virtual Reality
Vivo Vision Discovery Edition design reveal
This is Vivo's mixed reality headset
Samsung Project Moohan on display
Google ignored Android XR at GDC 2025, and indie VR devs are concerned
A panel of VR experts on stage at GDC 2025, discussing the "VR gaming visibility crisis."
Quest developers are joining forces to solve the 'VR visibility crisis'
A mockup of a mixed reality ornate ballroom with a Meta Quest 3. Ballroom made with Adobe AI
This new Meta Quest v74 feature is set to revolutionize immersive experiences
A promo image of the Meta Quest 3 on a grid background surrounded by eight bestselling VR titles in 2024, including Gorilla Tag and Batman: Arkham Shadow.
Meta's head of Oculus Publishing debunked Quest Store 'theories' and hinted at their Quest 4 audience at GDC
An official Gorilla Tag screenshot made to look like a "monke" is wearing a pink support headset
Gorilla Tag finally fixed its voice moderation problem
Latest in Feature
Comparing the display size on the Samsung Galaxy S25 with the Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus
What you need to know about One UI 7: Software is hard
The Moto 360 smartwatch worn on a wrist, showing an analog watch face.
Wear OS is still missing a major player, and now's the perfect time for a comeback
AirPods Max (left) hanging from a park bench beside Beats Studio Pro (right).
USB-C AirPods Max are getting an upgrade Android headphones had all along
Android statues
Ask Jerry: What happens if Google ignores the EU's DMA rules?
The Pixel 9a and Pixel 9
Google should've split the difference between the Pixel 9 and 9a
Comparing the displays between the Samsung Galaxy S24 Ultra and Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
Samsung displays aren't the gold standard you think they are