Google calls out the DOJ for its 'extreme' plan to break up its search business

A statue of the multicolored "G" in Google on the Google campus in Mountain View
(Image credit: Michael Hicks / Android Central)

What you need to know

  • Google is pushing back against the DOJ, calling its plan to break up Google Search an "extreme" move.
  • The DOJ’s 23-page proposal came after a court ruled that Alphabet broke antitrust laws by paying Samsung and Apple to keep Google as the default search engine.
  • The DOJ wants Google to divest Chrome, arguing it would give other search engines a shot at competing.
  • Google’s Kent Walker warns the plan could hurt user privacy, security, and product quality.

Google has hit back at the U.S. Department of Justice, accusing it of pushing a "radical interventionist agenda" to break its search business.

According to a report from Associated Press, the DOJ has made it official—it’s coming for Google’s search monopoly. After Judge Amit Mehta ruled against the tech giant, the DOJ issued a 23-page proposal detailing its plan to force Google to part ways with Chrome and tighten the reins on Android.

Back in August, a U.S. court called out Alphabet for throwing billions at Samsung and Apple to keep Google as the default search engine. Judge Mehta ruled the tactic straight-up broke antitrust laws.

The DOJ argues that cutting Chrome loose would strip Google of a key internet gateway, giving rival search engines a fair shot to compete.

Alphabet isn’t backing down from what it calls the DOJ’s “extreme" proposal. Kent Walker, Google’s global affairs chief, argued that splitting off Chrome and Android could hurt user security, privacy, and the overall quality of their products.

Walker raised concerns that the DOJ’s plan might force Google to share sensitive info—like proprietary tech and even personal search queries from millions of Americans—with unknown entities at home and abroad.

He also slammed the DOJ’s proposal for adding extra steps for Pixel users, requiring two separate choice screens just to get to Google Search.

Walker also warned that the DOJ’s plan could leak trade secrets to foreign companies, slow down AI progress, and have major negative effects on the global tech landscape.

The DOJ’s proposal goes way beyond what the court decided, targeting not just Google Search but a whole range of beloved Google products used around the globe, Walker wrote.

The DOJ has been taking aim at Alphabet’s habit of pre-installing Google products on Android, suggesting both "behavioral and structural fixes" to stop Google from using its power in Chrome, the Play Store, and Android to unfairly push Google Search.

Jay Bonggolto
News Writer & Reviewer

Jay Bonggolto always keeps a nose for news. He has been writing about consumer tech and apps for as long as he can remember, and he has used a variety of Android phones since falling in love with Jelly Bean. Send him a direct message via Twitter or LinkedIn.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.

Read more
Google Chrome logo at 2024 Fall Chromebook Event
The DOJ’s latest proposal still wants Google to cut Chrome loose
Apple and Google logos
Apple steps in to defend Google, says it 'does not plan to create a search engine' of its own
A photo of the Google Logo surrounded by plants at the company's NYC headquarters building
EU Commission finds that Google Search and Play Store fail to comply with the Digital Markets Act
Android statues
Ask Jerry: What happens if Google ignores the EU's DMA rules?
Amazon Appstore
Amazon abandoning its Appstore only makes Google's lock stronger
Comparing the sizes and shapes of the displays on the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra, Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus, and Samsung Galaxy S25
Is the partnership between Samsung and Google ruining the Android ecosystem?
Latest in Apps & Software
The Google Maps logo at the Google Maps Street View Garage
Google Maps might predict more than just the traffic for you soon
Top Charts in the Play Store on the Galaxy S25 Ultra
Google Play Store will get more tools to protect users from scammy apps
Google Gemini Image Query on Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Gemini could soon allow you to upload multiple images in a single prompt
Google Maps on Android Auto
Gemini could soon replace Google Assistant in Android Auto 14.0
Gemini 2.5 Pro graphics and benchmark results.
Gemini 2.5 Pro is Google's latest AI model with thinking and multimodality built-in
View of the lock screen on the Galaxy S25 Ultra
Samsung wants third-party apps to be compatible with Now Bar
Latest in News
The Google Maps logo at the Google Maps Street View Garage
Google Maps might predict more than just the traffic for you soon
Top Charts in the Play Store on the Galaxy S25 Ultra
Google Play Store will get more tools to protect users from scammy apps
Google Gemini Image Query on Google Pixel 9 Pro XL
Gemini could soon allow you to upload multiple images in a single prompt
Google Maps on Android Auto
Gemini could soon replace Google Assistant in Android Auto 14.0
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 on cobblestone road
One UI 7 Beta 3 for the Galaxy Z Flip 6, Fold 6 brings two notable AI additions
Gemini 2.5 Pro graphics and benchmark results.
Gemini 2.5 Pro is Google's latest AI model with thinking and multimodality built-in